McDonogh-Gilman Football Rivalry - Athletics & Equestrian - McDonogh School

McDonogh-Gilman Football Rivalry

The Eagles versus the Greyhounds. The Orange and Black versus the Blue and Gray. Two teams, one rivalry for the ages.

Since 1914, players and coaches of McDonogh and Gilman have met on the football field nearly every fall, giving their all for the second-oldest interscholastic rivalry in Maryland. This football classic has become a tradition spanning generations, connecting alumni, families, students, faculty and staff, and fans who have filled the stands to cheer on the Eagles and the Greyhounds for more than a century, across 109 games — and counting!

Mutual respect and good sportsmanship have long been at the core of this rivalry. Since 1947, the winning school has been awarded the Price Memorial Trophy, given in honor of the alumni from both schools who served together in World War II. Today, when the final whistle sounds, players from both teams shake hands and take a knee together while the two heads of school address them and the trophy changes hands. In recent years, a new and quickly beloved tradition has also taken root. In the week before the game, team members and student leaders from each school visit the other's campus to read with and get to know Lower School students, inspiring future generations and reminding everyone that the rivalry is fierce but friendly.

Read on to explore the stories, traditions, and year-by-year records that have made the McDonogh-Gilman game one of the most anticipated events on our calendar, and one that continues to bring two great school communities together.

Did You Know?

  • In the early years, before the teams adopted the Eagle and the Greyhound as mascots, sportswriters called McDonogh the "Farmers" and Gilman the "Roland Parkers." The teams have also been known as the "Cadets" and the "Gilmanites."
  • The game has ended in a tie five times, including scoreless ties in 1919 and 1948. The last tie was in 1957.
  • In 1962, both teams entered the game undefeated in their respective seasons thus far.
  • Four games in the rivalry have been decided by a single point, and McDonogh won two of them: an 8-7 win in 1963 and a 14-13 win in 1981, the first game in the rivalry decided in overtime.
  • McDonogh's largest margin of victory in the series came in 1959, a 46-0 win. The Eagles' 40-0 win in 1969 ranks second.
  • McDonogh has shut out Gilman 12 times, including the Eagles' first-ever win in the series, 6-0 in 1927; three straight shutouts from 1937 to 1939; and, most recently, a 31-0 win in 2025.
  • McDonogh has won seven consecutive games against Gilman (2018–2025; no game was played in 2020), the longest winning streak in the Eagles' history in the series.

The 110th McDonogh-Gilman Football Game

Saturday, November 7, 2026 @ 2:00 p.m.

Host: Gilman School

109

All-Time McDonogh-Gilman Meetings (1914–2025)

43-61-5

Eagles' All-Time Record Against the Greyhounds (W-L-T)

1,492

Points for McDonogh in All Meetings

7

Longest Streak of Consecutive Eagles Wins (2018–2025)

11,000+ 

Largest Known Crowd at a Game (100th Game in 2015)

3

Years the game was not played, each time due to a health crisis (1916, 1918, 2020)

History, Traditions, and Spirit

The First 100 Years of the Rivalry

The annual McDonogh vs. Gilman football game, the second-oldest interscholastic rivalry in the state of Maryland, was first played at Gilman on October 12, 1914. Gilman was victorious that day, 35-0. McDonogh's first victory came in 1927.

For the thousands of fans who attended the 48th McDonogh-Gilman game on November 22, 1963, it was a day they will never forget. That afternoon, shortly before kickoff at John McDonogh Stadium, the crowd of 4,000 was learning of the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. Both schools agreed to play the game, and although McDonogh won by a point in the low-scoring game, the outcome felt inconsequential.

Norman Parker '73 recalled, "Decorating the buses was always a big deal and very exciting when we were young. Everyone competed to win the prize for the best bus decorations leading up to the Gilman game."

An estimated 1,100 fans filled John McDonogh Stadium for the 100th game of the rivalry on November 7, 2015. While the score of the game was close (35-28) with Gilman earning the victory, the spectacular day-long celebration hosted by McDonogh was most memorable.

This content is adapted from content originally published in 150 Stories from McDonogh School's First 150 Years (2025).

An Iconic Venue: John McDonogh Stadium

John McDonogh Stadium was constructed under the auspices of the Public Works Administration (PWA). The government contributed 77% of the cost, and the Patrons Club contributed the balance. According to former Director of Maintenance Steve Simmers '70, the original track and field, built by the Works Progress Administration (WPA), is like "a Roman Road" with eight feet of foundation beneath the track and drainage tiles in the field. Dedicated in 1938, some 6,000 people were on hand for the 23rd annual football game against Gilman. Festivities began with a parade led by a pony mascot and ended with a 13-0 victory.

As a student, Darrius Heyward-Bey '05 dreamed of playing football under the lights in John McDonogh Stadium and promised that if he went "pro," he would donate the funds for lights. "Because," he said, "night games are what high school football is all about." He made good on his promise, and in September 2014, McDonogh held its first home Friday night football game in John McDonogh Stadium.

This content is adapted from content originally published in 150 Stories from McDonogh School's First 150 Years (2025).

The Price Memorial Trophy

First presented in 1947 by David W. Price '42 to the winner of the McDonogh vs. Gilman game, the Price Memorial Trophy was a memorial to the graduates of the two schools who fought together in World War II. Henry H. Callard, Gilman's Headmaster at the time, said, "The two schools have very much in common, even though we fight it out for all we are worth on the athletic field. The War did a great deal to bring boys together, and I like to think that athletic contests will be followed by a friendly spirit and mutual interests."

The winning school keeps the Price trophy until the next year. In the case of a tie score, as happened in 1957, each school holds the trophy for half a year, and a coin toss determines which team has the trophy for the first six months.

This content is adapted from content originally published in 150 Stories from McDonogh School's First 150 Years (2025).

Origins of the School Colors and Eagle Mascot

After Daniel Hauer (1888) and fellow student Benjamin A. Franklin (1887) formed the School's first football team in 1887, they selected orange and black as McDonogh's colors. Almost 90 years later, when McDonogh School dropped its semi-military program in 1971, the time was right for an official school mascot. For years prior, sportswriters had referred to McDonogh players as the "Farmers" or "The Cadets."

The student body was tasked with finding a new nickname as part of the overall change for the School, and the "Eagles" won the popular vote — a tribute to the eagle depicted on the McDonogh School seal and on the cadets' uniform hat. A coordinating committee got to work designing the new mascot, and E. Carey Kenney, the head of the Art Department, made their ideas a reality. Before long, an Eagle costume was created, and Jeffrey Rogers (1974), a boisterous member of the cheerleading squad, was selected to wear it. Despite the heavy head and the stifling hot, feathered outfit, wearing the Eagle costume was, and still is, a popular duty.

In 2026, the Eagle received its first major redesign in several decades.

This content is adapted from content originally published in 150 Stories from McDonogh School's First 150 Years (2025).

Traditions in the Lead-Up to the Big Game

We Love a Parade

McDonogh's annual Spirit Parade, held the day before the football game against time-honored archrival Gilman, isn't your typical parade. Sure, it has costumes, floats, bands, and more orange and black than imaginable, but it is also one in which spectators are participants and participants are spectators. The one-of-a-kind, double-self-enveloping spirit parade, designed by longtime faculty member Dave Harley, winds its way around campus and ends with an all-school pep rally.

For years, when Gilman hosted the game, the Eagles made their presence known when students, faculty, and alumni — a sea of festive orange and black — marched over the bridge from Bryn Mawr to Gilman led by drums, bagpipes, and, of course, Mr. Harley.

Drum Corps Marches On

With shiny orange and white drums resting squarely on their shoulders, members of McDonogh's Drum Corps have set the tone at important events for decades. Today's corps — comprised of third and fourth grade girls and boys — are proud participants in the annual schoolwide Spirit Parade, and they lead the fourth graders down Chapel Hill at the Lower School Closing Ceremony.

The Lower School Corps comes from a long line of drummers as far back as 1889. In October 1900, The Week reported, "Instead of having but three small drums, Mr. Williamson organized a fife and drum corps. Now there are six fifers, three buglers, three drummers, and one bass drum. The boys can march by this better than they could with only the drums, and it sounds much better." The story continues, "As the boys do not know how to play very well, we are not on the drill ground, but practicing in Mr. Williamson's classroom during drill time. I suppose we will be able to play by Founder's Day."

While the Fife and Drum Corps didn't survive, over the years, the music program grew. By the 1930s, it included a marching band that played for drill and at games and an orchestra that played at school dances. The orchestra also performed at the Christmas Bazaar and the Orange and Black Varieties with the Glee Club.

This content is adapted from content originally published in 150 Stories from McDonogh School's First 150 Years (2025).

Year-by-Year Records, Decade Results, Head Coaches, and Captains

2020–2029

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

2020

No Game

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2021

McDonogh: 45 (W) | Gilman: 6 (L)

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2022

McDonogh: 34 (W) | Gilman: 13 (L)

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2023

McDonogh: 21 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2024

McDonogh: 21 (W) | Gilman: 3 (L)

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2025

McDonogh: 31 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2026

—

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2027

—

—

—

2028

—

—

—

2029

—

—

—

Decade Record: McDonogh: 5 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L) | Ties: 0

2010–2019

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

2010

McDonogh: 6 (L) | Gilman: 42 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Eric A. Conway, Jr.
Albert C. Davila
Evan A. Grant

2011

McDonogh: 21 (L) | Gilman: 31 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Roman J. Braglio
Joel N. Jorgensen

2012*

McDonogh: 12 (L) | Gilman: 48 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Taysean J. Scott
Travis H. Wood

2013

McDonogh: 37 (W) | Gilman: 6 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

Sylvanus I. Brown
Jared R. Cohen
Wyatt M. Cook
Ryan G. Ford
Alexander F. Hurdle

2014

McDonogh: 21 (W) | Gilman: 14 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

Wyatt M. Cook
Ellis C. McKennie III
Akeem W. Myers-Blakney

2015

McDonogh: 28 (L) | Gilman: 35 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

—

2016

McDonogh: 42 (W) | Gilman: 6 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

—

2017

McDonogh: 21 (L) | Gilman: 24 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

—

2018

McDonogh: 33 (W) | Gilman: 8 (L)

Hakeem Sule '05

—

2019

McDonogh: 45 (W) | Gilman: 6 (L)

Hakeem Sule '05

—

Decade Record: McDonogh: 5 (T) | Gilman: 5 (T) | Ties: 0

*The 2012 season brought something new to the rivalry: a second meeting. After both teams earned berths in the MIAA A Conference playoffs, McDonogh and Gilman met again in the semifinals, where Gilman won 20-8. Because it was a postseason game, it is not included in the series record.

2000–2009

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

2000

McDonogh: 7 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

Taylor B. Callaham
Eric S. Hamilton II
Kellen F. Williams

2001

McDonogh: 14 (L) | Gilman: 17 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Joseph R. Benson
Edward C. Dolch, Jr.
Eric S. Hamilton II
Russell A. Mason
Geoffrey E. Miller

2002

McDonogh: 14 (L) | Gilman: 35 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Samuel S. Coe
Travis D. Holmes
Trevor C. Williams

2003

McDonogh: 10 (W) | Gilman: 6 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

Corey T. Davis, Jr.
Cameron S. Goldberg
Nicholas M. Marshall
Von William F. Torgee

2004

McDonogh: 24 (L) | Gilman: 28 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Darrius R. Heyward-Bey
Bryn T. Holmes
Anthony L. Lott, Jr.
Hakeem O. Sule, Jr.

2005

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 28 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Timothy J. Brandau
Kelley C. Cox
Bryn T. Holmes
Willie R. Norton
Kyle R. O'Brien

2006

McDonogh: 22 (W) | Gilman: 16 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

Steven M. Banks
Robert M. Ford
James T. Hood IV
Jared M. Jorgensen
David C. Klein

2007

McDonogh: 14 (L) | Gilman: 21 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Lane W. Clelland
Tyler C. Goldberg
Malcolm K. Moses-Hampton
Douglas P. Schenk, Jr.
Kacey R. Woods

2008

McDonogh: 22 (W) | Gilman: 14 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

Bryan Q. Ellis, Jr.
Curtis M. Holmes
Rudolph C. Johnson III

2009

McDonogh: 27 (L) | Gilman: 34 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Bryan Q. Ellis, Jr.
Ross M. Farquharson
Rudolph C. Johnson III
Isaac D. Jorgensen
Gabriel M. Macis

Decade Record: McDonogh: 4 (L) | Gilman: 6 (W) | Ties: 0

1990–1999

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1990

McDonogh: 8 (L) | Gilman: 20 (W)

Michael S. McMillan

D. Jermain Johnson
James F. Lewis IV
Eric B. Nichols
Julian E. S. Wright

1991

McDonogh: 24 (W) | Gilman: 17 (L)

R. Michael Working '66

Derrick M. McCoy
Jabari M. Miller

1992

McDonogh: 17 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

R. Michael Working '66

Timothy L. Yeager

1993

McDonogh: 20 (W) | Gilman: 10 (L)

R. Michael Working '66

Clinton J. Fuchs
Derek J. Lindsey II
R. Michael Working, Jr.

1994

McDonogh: 35 (L) | Gilman: 38 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Vance J. Row
Robert G. Sabelhaus, Jr.
C. Dwayne L. Stukes

1995

McDonogh: 2 (L) | Gilman: 18 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Timothy M. Cober, Jr.
Jeffrey D. Miyamoto
Matthew H. Osborne

1996

McDonogh: 25 (W) | Gilman: 21 (L)

Dominic F. Damico

Lance M. Clelland
Robert B. Reeves
Philip J. Rosenbaum
Cephus Smith III
Cornell O. Williams

1997

McDonogh: 20 (L) | Gilman: 32 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Anthony J. Esposito
Neil J. Littman
John A. Reynolds
Cornell O. Williams

1998

McDonogh: 14 (L) | Gilman: 23 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Owen Daly IV
Anthony J. Esposito
Brian D. McGregor
Matthew L. Primm
Evan R. Weinberg

1999

McDonogh: 10 (L) | Gilman: 42 (W)

Dominic F. Damico

Thurgood Deland Cosby, Jr.
Scott B. Dolch
Eric D. King, Jr.
Kenneth Sanders II
William J. Shek

Decade Record: McDonogh: 4 (L) | Gilman: 6 (W) | Ties: 0

1980–1989

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1980

McDonogh: 21 (W) | Gilman: 14 (L)

Michael S. McMillan

Richard A. Bosley
Thomas T. Neubauer
Charles K. Rafferty

1981

McDonogh: 14 (W) | Gilman: 13 (L)

Michael S. McMillan

Evan T. Booker
W. Craig Fitchett
Michael P. McIntyre

1982

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 25 (W)

Michael S. McMillan

W. Garth Kilburn
Paul M. Meurer
Todd R. Smith

1983

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 7 (W)

Michael S. McMillan

Karl F. Lehmann
Scott P. Recher
Todd R. Smith

1984

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 21 (W)

Michael S. McMillan

Gian F. Alecce
Derek S. McEwen
James A. Sweeney, Jr.

1985

McDonogh: 6 (W) | Gilman: 3 (L)

Michael S. McMillan

Mark A. Koski
John J. Rallo III
Robert L. Young III

1986

McDonogh: 7 (L) | Gilman: 8 (W)

Michael S. McMillan

John M. Gast
Peter C. Pittroff II
Alan T. Robinson

1987

McDonogh: 35 (W) | Gilman: 12 (L)

Michael S. McMillan

Antoine W. Burgess
J. Casey Clark, Jr.
Andrew B. Linden
Damon H. Young

1988

McDonogh: 14 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

Michael S. McMillan

Michael L. McMillan
Robert W. Newton
Kevin M. Wilson

1989

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 35 (W)

Michael S. McMillan

Michael A. Davis
Stanley K. Dorsey

Decade Record: McDonogh: 5 (T) | Gilman: 5 (T) | Ties: 0

1970–1979

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1970

McDonogh: 21 (W) | Gilman: 12 (L)

C. Richard Working

Wayne B. Rudick

1971

McDonogh: 12 (L) | Gilman: 14 (W)

C. Richard Working

Robert F. Lindsey

1972

McDonogh: 12 (L) | Gilman: 26 (W)

C. Richard Working

Jack B. Dudley
Norvain T. Sharps II

1973

McDonogh: 6 (L) | Gilman: 42 (W)

Gerald F. Pfeifer
C. Richard Working

Kevin T. Moore
George C. Mullinix, Jr.

1974

McDonogh: 20 (L) | Gilman: 26 (W)

Gerald F. Pfeifer

T. Patrick Dulany
C. Duke Duncan, Jr.

1975

McDonogh: 19 (L) | Gilman: 34 (W)

Gerald F. Pfeifer

LeRoy B. Katz
Kip W. White, Jr.

1976

McDonogh: 6 (L) | Gilman: 36 (W)

Gerald F. Pfeifer

Ronald I. Chesek
John M. Kemp
Thomas E. Sausser

1977

McDonogh: 7 (L) | Gilman: 29 (W)

Gerald F. Pfeifer

Stanley J. Kraska, Jr.
D. Jonathan Merriman

1978

McDonogh: 8 (L) | Gilman: 35 (W)

Michael S. McMillan

Kenneth S. Bode
Michael E. Crook
Lenwood D. Johnson

1979

McDonogh: 21 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Michael S. McMillan

Jerry A. Clarke
David K. Johnstone III
Chad B. Woodburn

Decade Record: McDonogh: 2 (L) | Gilman: 8 (W) | Ties: 0

1960–1969

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1960

McDonogh: 22 (W) | Gilman: 8 (L)

C. Richard Working

A. Monroe Hubbard
R. Bruce Kyle

1961

McDonogh: 8 (L) | Gilman: 22 (W)

C. Richard Working

Daniel M. Davis III
Thomas L. Peddy

1962

McDonogh: 6 (L) | Gilman: 21 (W)

C. Richard Working

John S. Urban

1963

McDonogh: 8 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

C. Richard Working

Andrew F. Beath
Martin H. Carter

1964

McDonogh: 8 (L) | Gilman: 15 (W)

C. Richard Working

Jerry Babicka

1965

McDonogh: 6 (L) | Gilman: 22 (W)

C. Richard Working

Frank J. Marsden III

1966

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 28 (W)

C. Richard Working

Richard C. Hogg
Thomas B. Logan

1967

McDonogh: 16 (L) | Gilman: 28 (W)

C. Richard Working

Richard J. Bukowsky
William C. Ellis
Scott A. Gibbs

1968

McDonogh: 8 (L) | Gilman: 22 (W)

C. Richard Working

Michael O. Farrell

1969

McDonogh: 40 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

C. Richard Working

William J. Howley III
Robert E. Rice

Decade Record: McDonogh: 3 (L) | Gilman: 7 (W) | Ties: 0

1950–1959

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1950

McDonogh: 7 (L) | Gilman: 14 (W)

Howard C. Eyth

Kenneth E. Armiger
Hugo P. Colombi

1951

McDonogh: 12 (L) | Gilman: 13 (W)

Howard C. Eyth

Robert J. Doub
Nicholas J. Robinson

1952

McDonogh: 6 (T) | Gilman: 6 (T)

Howard C. Eyth

Edmund S. Mesko
Herbert E. Wilgis, Jr.

1953

McDonogh: 19 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

Howard C. Eyth

John J. Cooper

1954

McDonogh: 34 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

C. Richard Working

H. Bernard Dorshow
Richard E. Kieeny, Jr.

1955

McDonogh: 7 (L) | Gilman: 20 (W)

C. Richard Working

Richard W. Virgilio

1956

McDonogh: 14 (L) | Gilman: 39 (W)

C. Richard Working

John P. Daiger

1957

McDonogh: 7 (T) | Gilman: 7 (T)

C. Richard Working

Nevett Steele, Jr.

1958

McDonogh: 30 (W) | Gilman: 13 (L)

C. Richard Working

Robert C. Rogers, Jr.

1959

McDonogh: 46 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

C. Richard Working

Scott B. Harris
James E. Welsch

Decade Record: McDonogh: 4 (T) | Gilman: 4 (T) | Ties: 2

1940–1949

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1940

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 25 (W)

Herbert E. Armstrong

Raymond B. Oliver

1941

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 29 (W)

Herbert E. Armstrong

James D. Lynch

1942

McDonogh: 14 (W) | Gilman: 12 (L)

Robert C. Lynch '28

George C. Mullinix

1943

McDonogh: 14 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

Robert C. Lynch '28

John T. Sadler, Jr.

1944

McDonogh: 6 (T) | Gilman: 6 (T)

Robert C. Lynch '28

Raymond J. Hill, Jr.
Alvin V. Kollosch

1945

McDonogh: 6 (L) | Gilman: 20 (W)

Robert C. Lynch '28

Joseph D. Tydings
John W. Wenger

1946

McDonogh: 6 (L) | Gilman: 20 (W)

Howard C. Eyth

Thomas H. Inman

1947

McDonogh: 6 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Howard C. Eyth

John H. Howard, Jr.
Andrew L. Polzin

1948

McDonogh: 0 (T) | Gilman: 0 (T)

Howard C. Eyth

John H. Howard, Jr.
Andrew L. Polzin

1949

McDonogh: 32 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Howard C. Eyth

John A. Schwab, Jr.

Decade Record: McDonogh: 4 (T) | Gilman: 4 (T) | Ties: 2

1930–1939

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1930

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 19 (W)

Frank Barger

Edward L. Seitz

1931

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 27 (W)

Frank Barger

Willis A. DeMoss

1932

McDonogh: 14 (W) | Gilman: 7 (L)

Herbert E. Armstrong

Willis A. DeMoss

1933

McDonogh: 33 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Herbert E. Armstrong

Paul Horner

1934

McDonogh: 12 (W) | Gilman: 6 (L)

Herbert E. Armstrong

Charles W. Weidinger

1935

McDonogh: 7 (L) | Gilman: 12 (W)

Herbert E. Armstrong

John V. Dimling
Joshua L. Horner

1936

McDonogh: 7 (L) | Gilman: 12 (W)

Herbert E. Armstrong

Frank P. Sweeny

1937

McDonogh: 6 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Herbert E. Armstrong

Harry K. Baugher

1938

McDonogh: 13 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Herbert E. Armstrong

Harry G. Barnard

1939

McDonogh: 20 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Herbert E. Armstrong

A. Ludlam Michaux, Jr.

Decade Record: McDonogh: 6 (W) | Gilman: 4 (L) | Ties: 0

1920–1929

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1920

McDonogh: 7 (L) | Gilman: 16 (W)

Chester Des Rochers

Thomas M. Kelley

1921

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 45 (W)

Chester Des Rochers

Walter G. Hynson

1922

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 20 (W)

Chester Des Rochers

Walter V. Cowman

1923

McDonogh: 3 (L) | Gilman: 7 (W)

Chester Des Rochers

Walter E. Hutchinson

1924

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 27 (W)

Chester Des Rochers

William E. Cockey
William B. Randall

1925

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 27 (W)

Chester Des Rochers

Robert C. Lynch

1926

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 6 (W)

Chester Des Rochers

Robert C. Lynch

1927

McDonogh: 6 (W) | Gilman: 0 (L)

Frank Barger

Willis K. Lynch

1928

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 45 (W)

Frank Barger

Thomas F. Potter
Walter I. Tucker

1929

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 14 (W)

Frank Barger

Edward L. Seitz

Decade Record: McDonogh: 1 (L) | Gilman: 9 (W) | Ties: 0

1914–1919

YEAR

RESULT

HEAD COACH

CAPTAINS

1914

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 35 (W)

Morgan H. Bowman
John C. Branham '10

Harvey H. Smith

1915

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 20 (W)

R.L. Roe

John E. Bruce
Edwin H. Collins
Richard A. Horchner

1916

No Game

S. Warren Scott

Lawrence H. Pullen

1917

McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 10 (W)

Robert T. Norment

Richard T. Greason

1918

No Game

Morgan H. Bowman

Leonard D. Kinsey

1919

McDonogh: 0 (T) | Gilman: 0 (T)

Morgan H. Bowman

Carl H. Edel

Decade Record: McDonogh: 0 (L) | Gilman: 3 (W) | Ties: 1